Saturday, October 30, 2004
Macbeth
Production was very good and very standard (no odd modernist elements or background changes, just Shakespeare as it was meant to be done). There was one interesting non-standard element in the casting - a man (Bruce Evers, who did a very credible job with the part) was cast as one of the three weird sisters. An interesting choice; between his physical size and the way he was made up he actually looked a great deal like Tim Cassidy as Ruk in Star Trek:
Friday, October 29, 2004
Thai Food
My wife and I went to dinner at this Thai restaurant we frequent. She had baked catfish (usually we stay away from seafood at Thai restaurants but this place specializes in seafood). I went more traditional and had masaman curry, which is available with beef, pork or chicken. I asked the waiter which he recommended, and he instantly answered "beef." No hesitation, no equivocation, no fear! Beef. And he was right. Both entrees were very good, as usual. We highly recommend this place.
Tuesday, October 26, 2004
Bad Service
Sunday, October 24, 2004
Dune: House Harkonnen
Thinking for you. This book continues the mistake of Dune: House Atreides in insisting on digesting absolutely everything for you. One particularly blatant example is explaining the true nature of axlotl tanks. This had been hinted at but never spelled out in the original Dune Chronicles; it's better that way.
Bad writing. Not only do they continue to do the reader's thinking, but they do so with annoying repetitiveness. For example, on p. 206, they write, "There was no shame in it for Kailea, either, especially with her lack of prospects." Then on p. 208, they write, "For Kailea there would certainly be no shame in becoming the chosen lover of a Duke." This is just one example; there are dozens. They do this elsewhere; for example, describing the rugs in Earl Vernius's office (pointed out by an Amazon reviewer). Their repeated use of ridiculous phrases is beyond dumb. To mention just a few, "muscular" three times on one page, Kailea's "emerald" eyes, Jessica's "bronze" hair, "barrel-chested" "burly" Rabban, and Anirul's "doe eyes." The elecran chapter was a complete distraction; what point to introducing such an absurd creature (were they trying to follow Herbert Senior's brilliant conception of the sandworms? if so, they failed miserably!) if it matters not to the rest of the book? Chapter transitions are still choppy and distracting.
Boring Sections. Some of the plot lines are monumentally boring. In particular, Duncan Idaho's 8 years at the Ginaz Swordmaster School (which for some reason I can't quite put my finger on, I think are the chapters the authors would be most proud of) are beyond silly. And when you get to the end of the book and witness the Swordmasters' truly pathetic behavior, it makes you wish you had skipped all the chapters related to this particular plot line.
Clumsy Politics. The political universe which Frank Herbert created, which we believed had survived for 100 centuries, is shattered by the ridiculously clumsy actions that Herbert Junior & Anderson put their characters through. A universe in which people behaved this way wouldn't last 1 century before cataclysmic war took place.
Contradictions. The book contradicts the original Dune novel in too many places to mention exhaustively. They should have gone back and re-read the original before writing this.
Unbelievable Plot. Often the authors rely on lazy and contrived solving of plot lines (some are outright deus ex machina arrangements) just to make everything fit together. The motivations of some characters are even more ridiculous than Lady Helena's in the first book. Some actions are absurd and do not fit in with anything else we've ever read about the Dune universe (the Bene Gesserit when they are visited by the Baron Harkonnen).
Unlikeable Characters. Even after all of the above, the book would still be above average. Their worst sin, however, is that they simply write many of their characters in such a way that they are downright unlikeable. Abulurd Harkonnen needs to grow a pair. Earl Dominic Vernius is a despicable criminal, willing to commit an unthinkable atrocity simply for revenge (never mind that he lost control of Ix through his own indifferent leadership). With Rhombur, they seem to be going for the tragic hero, but instead end up depicting an ineffectual buffoon. Most unlikeable of all, Kailea is an annoying petulant beeyotch (although I think this plot line could have been infinitely improved if the readers -- like the characters -- did not find out what was really happening until the end, rather than being told at the beginning).
For all this, if you are a Dune fan, this book is still a somewhat enjoyable read. Herbert Junior & Anderson had the right plot ideas at the "macro" level (again I assume this is the result of Herbert Senior's notes and not their own brilliance) even if they failed to execute them properly at the "micro" level. I would rate this between 2 or 3 stars, a bit lower than Dune: House Atreides. Be back at ya after I read Dune: House Corrino.
Friday, October 22, 2004
Spaghetti Warehouse
Wednesday, October 20, 2004
The world is about to get a lot less funny, beginning in January
Dave Barry, The Miami Herald's humor columnist for the past 20 years, said Tuesday that he will take an indefinite leave of absence from the newspaper. He may return in a year. Herald editors wish Barry were making it up. ''Since Dave's columns began appearing every Sunday in The Herald, an entire generation has been born, raised and reached adulthood,'' said Tom Fiedler, The Herald's executive editor. ''Yet his unique sense of humor never grew up and never got old. Learning that Dave wants a breather is like hearing that Peter Pan joined AARP.'' Barry, 57, said he wants to spend more time with his family after a hectic summer trotting from the Democratic and Republican national conventions to the Olympics in Greece and around the country on a book promotion tour.[I guess I should thank DVD for bringing this to my attention, but I don't feel like it. To hell with not shooting the messenger.]
Sunday, October 17, 2004
Copeland's Restaurant
Something else worth mentioning is their Sunday brunch (through 3:00 p.m.), which includes several excellent choices. Not to be missed!
Saturday, October 16, 2004
Ice Cream
- Don't go too simple. The couple behind us ordered a plain vanilla and a plain chocolate. Don't do this. If you do, all you're getting is run-of-the-mill vanilla or chocolate and paying $2.99 for the privilege. If you want that, go get a half gallon in the grocery store. You go to Cold Stone for the mixings.
- Don't go too complex. If you start getting all experimental and trying to put together stuff that has no business being together (like strawberries and Reese's peanut butter cups), you will not be a happy camper. Stick to classic toppings, like Heath candy bar or cookie dough. Or even better, try one of their pre-designed combinations like mint mint chocolate chocolate or Founder's Favorite. We've never gone wrong with any of those varieties.
(Marble Slab Creamery is the same set-up. Also excellent!)
Sunday, October 10, 2004
Dune: House Atreides
Pros:
- The basic stories are interesting. Herbert & Anderson have done a good job of developing the original idea (presumably this is due to the fact that they are working from Herbert Senior's notes)
- The authors have done a good job of fleshing out the basic ideas into a fairly fast-paced and well-motivated plot. I was definitely interested enough to keep reading (despite the bad writing) to find out what happened next. I will be reading House Harkonnen, the next book in this series, as well.
- It's an easy read.
Cons:
- They spell everything out. The original Dune was well-known for its nuances and subtle writing. This book spells everything out for you; the political machinations in particular are beat to the death as the writers provide us with every single detail of how every single character arrives at a conclusion as to who's doing what and why.
- The writing level is just not on a par with the original series. Herbert Junior is clearly not as smart as Herbert Senior (who is?) and because of this writes as if the reader is too dumb to follow along. Well, I may not be as smart as Frank Herbert, but I'm definitely smarter than the authors. This sometimes makes the reading monotonous when they review something for the reader for the third or fourth time. Some things (including most of what they spell out) are better left for the reader to work out on his own.
- The character development is often not interesting or deep; some of the characters (e.g., Duke Leto's mother) are one-dimensional. It's often a mystery why they do what they do (can't elaborate without a plot spoiler, but trust me when I say that some plot twists are unbelievable).
- They use the same short chapter technique as the original, but each section is just too short. As a result, the action often feels jerky, rather than the smooth transitions the original managed to achieve.
- There are many disagreements with the original Dune series. So many in fact that they had to put out a spin sheet on the www.dunenovels.com website to explain away these discrepancies and errors.
- It's an easy read.
So, where does that leave us? Still not sure, maybe 3 stars out of 5? The only thing I can say with certainty is that it's neither as good as nor as bad as some of the reviews on Amazon would lead you to believe.
One More Restaurant Recommendation
Food, service and decor are all top-notch. My wife and I especially like their Duet Specials. On Wednesday nights and Saturday Early Bird (4-7 pm), they have a special for two. For $34.95, you get
- two martinis -- over fifty varieties from which to choose
- an appetizer -- all of them outstanding; the calamari deserve special mention since I'm not a big fan of calamari, but I love it the way Olive's prepares it very lightly fried; the mussells are also excellent
- two entrees -- excellently prepared, and huge; you will have leftovers
- dessert -- the creme brulee in particular is phenomenal
If you are in the Atlanta area, this is one restaurant deal that is not to be missed.
All you can eat
Friday, October 08, 2004
Sunday, October 03, 2004
By popular request
My wife and I went to Sonny's BBQ (www.sonnysbbq.com). We go there often; it's cheap and the food is very good. We ordered Chicken & Ribs, and the waiter tells us it's all you can eat night ... for the same price! Excellent! They have a variety of BBQ sauces that will literally leave you licking your fingers. I'm partial to the sweet sauce; my wife likes the spicier stuff. Their sides are top notch too, especially the cole slaw.
Saturday, October 02, 2004
Wow
I was surprised to learn today that something I posted at www.actuary.ca over a year ago seems to have surfaced in several places on the web in the last few days. I guess better late than never.
To see if this can actually generate some good discussion on education, I am going to create a separate blog where I will re-construct the original article from which my posts were created.
I must confess it was really cool to see my words all over the internet like that.
Friday, October 01, 2004
Food!
And attractive women. The problem is that my wife thinks comments like "She's attractive" are ok, but comments like "She's smokin' and I'd do her in a second if I weren't married (and she let me)" are not ok. Somewhere between those two is a line, but since I'm not sure exactly where the line is, it's best to avoid the subject of attractive women altogether.
I can talk about food, though. That's always ok with my wife.